Regret rate for trans surgery.
At 12 years old, Chloe Cole decided she was transgender.
Regret rate for trans surgery The regret rate for trans related surgeries is miles lower than the regret rate for things like knee or pelvis replacement surgeries. ; Maria Ibarra, M. 1 Within plastic surgery, there exists a wide fund of literature on decision regret following breast reconstruction and gender-reaffirming procedures. It is important to put conversations about regret of gender-affirming care into context with other types of medical care. For people interested in GAS (Gender Affirming Surgery) regret rates in the general populous, there's a meta analysis of 27 studies that used questionnaire techniques to estimate the incidence rate of GAS regret (pooled respondents Regret is rare among people who make a gender transition. (2021) 1, transitioning regret after getting gender-affirming surgery happens rarely. g. Regret rates for surgeries are actually pretty high even when "unexpected. and if 1% of those regret surgery, assuming a conservative 2. The study, conducted by experts from the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health The Numbers Tell a Different Story. It highlights the inconsistency in the regulation and discussion of medical procedures, noting a double standard in how gender-affirming surgeries Postoperative Regret Among Transgender and Gender-Diverse Recipients of Gender-Affirming Surgery JAMA Surg . ; Andrew Bolze, B. Transgender Surgery in India: Navigating Transformation. 2 Various studies with comparable follow-up times have investigated regret in other procedures, The regret rate following gender-affirming surgery is thought to be approximately 1%; however, previous studies relied heavily on ad hoc instruments. The adjusted suicide attempt risk The regret rates of transition are also extremely low for both youth 28 and adult trans people. , 2015; Kaltiala et al. For both TKA and THA patients, greater levels of DR were associated with poorer Oxford scores. A total of 77 patients regretted having Of the 30 % of surgeons that completed the survey, 61 % respondents had treated at least one patient who experienced regret or requested reversal of a procedure. 6% for Evidence suggests that less than 1% of transgender people who undergo gender-affirming surgery report regret. 4 Explanation about However, when rates of regret in gender-affirming surgery are compared with other surgical interventions, the results are striking. Patients who had a history of gender-affirmation surgery compared to patients without a gender-affirmation surgery history but had a vasectomy or BTL showed significantly higher risks for each outcome (Table 3). 3 Metastudy of 27 studies about trans regret: Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence – Valeria P. 4% 14. (2021) studies, including sample size, number of regrets, data collection method, follow-up rate, caveats to the regret rate, and web link. The study, published Wednesday in the journal JAMA Surgery, shows that people who had a gender-affirming mastectomy, sometimes called top surgery, had extremely low Based on this review, there is an extremely low prevalence of regret in transgender patients after GAS. 7 trans-women who sought detransition had vaginal stenosis, 2 had rectovaginal Top surgery is the most common gender-affirming medical procedure in the United States, and despite the narrative pushed by conservative politicians, the rate of regret is approximately 1%. 1016/j. In other surgical subspecialties, 30 % of patients experience regret following prostatectomy and up to 19. 1988;21:526–531. 3% for transgender men and 0. a recent meta-analysis finds a regret rate of just below 1% (Bustos et al. Read Blog . 1 This represents over 0. There is a paucity of literature examining the incidence and/or etiology of surgical de- and re-transition. " Knee surgeries, for example, that provides a lot of There are millions of people that are trans in the world, about 30% of those have transition surgery, at least in the u. , Farnebo, F. 3 percent of transgender men and 0. People who got gender affirming surgery, according to a now-viral social media post. Much of the opposition to adolescent transgender care has been ideologically motivated and reflects a wider attempt to restrict the rights of the LGBTQ+ community (Hines, 2020; Kraschel et al. We believe this study corroborates the improvements made in regard to selection criteria for GAS. Barbee et al. Not only is there a tremendously low regret rate for top surgery, it has also been shown to be associated with consistent improvements in patient satisfaction with their body and overall appearance. 6052. Regrets are most likely to result from a lack of social support after transition or poor surgical outcomes using older techniques. , 2019) included participants followed up for one year or less, an even shorter time than the shortest observed Transgender advocates have worked to create a false narrative, hoodwinking the world into believing that no one ever has regrets from a surgical change of gender. Sex reassignment surgery in male to female trans-sexuals. I'm a medical doctor, psychiatrist, WPATH GEI SOC8 certified member, and gender res At 12 years old, Chloe Cole decided she was transgender. Even though surgery and hormonal therapy alleviates gender dysphoria, it is apparently not sufficient to remedy the high rates of morbidity and mortality found among transsexual persons. Overall, the calculated rate of regret after gender The Instagram post claims that only 1% of patients regret their gender transition surgeries. 3% to 3%. jos A study into the rate of regret for top surgery has confirmed that it improves life for the overwhelming majority. Even though some patients develop severe surgical complications they seldom regret having undergone surgery. 6% for transwomen and 0. Surgery The viewpoint draws on a prior study on the topic, a meta analysis of over 7,000 patients that found a strikingly low regret rate - less than 1% postoperative regret for both transmasculine individuals and for transfeminine people. That proportion is even more striking when compared to the fact that 14. , 2018). RULE 5: THIS SUB IS FOR AND BY TRANS PEOPLE. Clearly, this is a group at high risk for dangerous levels of depression The updated transgender treatment guidelines note that some teens who detransition “do not regret initiating treatment” because they felt it helped them better understand their gender-related Gender-affirming surgeries have one of the lowest regret rates of any major surgery. Media coverage tends to focus on case A Dutch study, which is often cited as demonstrating a low rate of regret in transgender adults following medical transition, illustrates how selection bias and high rates of loss to follow-up might lead to underestimates of regret (Wiepjes et al. 3 Both O’Malley and colleagues Research consistently demonstrates that regret rates for gender-affirming surgeries are exceptionally low. Otherwise clinicians wouldn't be performing surgery at all (with ~14% regret rate). 1001/jamasurg. The TG-Intestinal (n = 580) and VA-Intestinal (n = 603) cohorts featured low rates of peritonitis or anastomotic leak and small intestinal obstruction or ileus According to various statistics, there is no exact number of trans people who regret having transition surgery from male to female or vice versa. Generally speaking, studies have stated that Bottom surgery carries a regret rate of 1% or less, which is extremely low compared to regret rates for other surgeries (knee replacement has 20% for example). 8 Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, University of Rochester Medical Center, Strong Memorial Hospital, Rochester, N. Roberto D’Angelo along with Pablo Expósito-Campos just published a letter to the editor of the journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery – Global Open in response to a publication that asserted that gender assignment surgery regret is very low. Nonetheless, we don’t In a review of 27 studies involving almost 8,000 teens and adults who had transgender surgeries, mostly in Europe, the U. Bustos et al, 19th March 2021 . A 2021 systemic review of the medical literature, surgery: a prospective follow-up study. , 2011; Lawrence, 2003, Only 9% felt most authentic while identifying as transgender. 3% for transmen with an average time to regret of 10. Transgender Surgery: Regret Rates Highest in Male-to-Female Reassignment Operations. Even though data on trans people post medical transition show continuing high rates of mental health problems, higher suicide risk and physical health problems, it is often reported that dysphoria is mitigated by transition and that mental health generally . 2024 Feb 1;159(2):125-126. Regret following gender-affirming surgery is extremely rare, with studies showing rates of regret ranging from 0. Not just that, but the road to trans-surgery is incredibly long, and there are a lot of steps in between, all of which are strictly monitored by doctors and therapists. At 13, she was put on puberty blockers and prescribed testosterone. . 6 percent) among the general population. doi: 10. Reply Additional Info: just an FYI. Thornton, Armin Edalatpour, Katherine M. What percentage of transgender regret surgery. PMID Decision regret, which refers to distress or remorse over a health care decision, can occur in any patient undergoing any medical intervention. For those new to this issue, it’s best to know these terms before reading. Gender-affirming surgery (GAS) has been shown to improve quality of life and alleviate gender This study found a rate of regret of less than 1% among transgender men and women “who underwent gonadectomy,” or removal of the testes or ovaries, from 1972 Now, a new systematic review published in The American Journal of Surgery has concluded that the rate of regret for transgender surgeries is "remarkably low. 2,3 Multiple studies also exist that investigate postoperative satisfaction In general, these studies have found post-surgery regret to be low (Dhejne et al. AFAIK, that alleged 1% trans regret rate would indeed be the lowest of any medical procedure , including indisputably lifesaving treatments, were it accurate. saw a report on "trans" , published in 2016, by a department at UCLA which compiled data on # of trans in the US. A new study shows a very low rate of regret among kids taking puberty blockers or hormones as part of gender-affirming care. Y. Among those that underwent gonadectomy, rates of regret were 0. ; from the A sub for the discussion of surgeries, surgery results, surgeon satisfaction and the costs incurred by transgender people. One Dutch study of nearly 7,000 transgender people found that the rate of regret was less than 1% among those who received treatment as adults – and there were no cases of regret among those who received care before the age of 18. High patient satisfaction, improved dysphoria, and reduced mental health comorbidities persist decades after GAS without any reported patient regret. These low numbers suggest that the vast Updated October 23, 2024 at 12:28 PM ET. D’Angelo and Expósito-Campos point out the critical need for accuracy in this figure and that The regret rate for surgery to treat back pain is way higher. There were 15 (5 MF and 10 MF) regret applications corresponding to a 2. 5 Center for Our current rate of 0. Conclusion: Self-reported decisional regret was present in about 1 in 7 surgical patients. 3%) expressed a desire to reverse their gender transition. Provided that your surgeon is well vetted and you desire the surgery, the chances are extremely low that you will regret the surgery. 2% across both sexes. Systematic reviews of regret related to non gender-affirming surgical interventions found an average regret rate of 14%–21% []. Besides, people regret not just plastic surgeries (that are usually portrayed as frivolous According to Danker et al. , 2012). The information that does exist appears to corroborate Asquith’s claim. The study included nearly 7000 patients who sought hormonal therapy and surgery from 1972 The authors of the March 2021 Gender Affirming Surgery Mini-series article entitled “Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence” (Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. Nonetheless, some of the Gender-affirming care is banned for transgender youth when it's mainly cisgender people who use it, and when it has a significantly lower regret rate than all other major surgeries, tattoos, and "Transgender surgery is done with full consent of the individual," Bowers, who does gender-affirming genital surgeries and restorative surgeries for female genital mutilation survivors, told PolitiFact in November 2023. 2 Transgender Health Program. [1] The term is distinct from the concept of 'regret', and the decision may be based on a number of reasons, including a shift in gender identity, health concerns, social or economic pressure, discrimination, stigma, [2 This survey study examines rates of satisfaction, regret, and continuity of care in adolescents who received puberty blockers and/or gender-affirming puberty blockers or hormones were detailed by the youth and/or their parents as part Background: Lasting regret after gender-affirming surgery (GAS) is a difficult multifaceted clinical scenario with profound effects on individual well-being as well as being a politically charged topic. This article summarizes the authors' Gender-affirming surgery is a durable treatment that improves overall patient well-being. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility: The regret rate for gender-affirming surgery is relatively low. While the success rates are impressive, it’s also important to discuss the gender-affirming surgery regret rate. 8%, with 0. , Rinder, J. Jamie (she/they). Published Oct 03, 2017 at 1:30 PM EDT Updated Oct 03, 2017 at 4:43 PM EDT. (2013) found a regret rate prevalence of 0. In regretting gender affirming surgery, someone is essentially saying they regret becoming who they are in a consequential-feeling sense. In our data alone, only 1% of patients reported having some degree of regret after surgery and 41% desire to have a phalloplasty in the future. BACKGROUND: Regret after gender-affirming surgery is considered a rare outcome. transgender or gender Factors most often associated with regret included type of surgery, disease-specific quality of life, and shared decision making. For context, the average “regret rate” for plastic surgeries is around 4%. A comprehensive study published in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery in 2021 found that only 1% of patients who underwent gender-affirming surgeries reported regret. It's the latest research from the Objective: To examine rates of satisfaction, regret, and 2023 online survey wave of an ongoing longitudinal study, the Trans Youth Project, among a community-based sample of transgender youth and their parents initially recruited throughout the US and Canada between 2013 and 2017. Research published on Wednesday (9 August) involved 235 patients who had undergone a gender-affirming After propensity matching of cohorts A and C, each cohort had 1,489 patients of similar age at index, race, and ethnicity (Tables 3-4). S and Canada, 1% Additionally, the Associated Press reported in March that only about 1 percent of individuals who had transgender surgeries expressed regret. First, both groups of authors take issue with the 1% regret rate (ie, the proportion of people who will regret their decision to transition), originally stated in The Lancet Child & Adolescent Health's Editorial. It might be worth mentioning here that studies for nearly all surgical procedures are far higher than the 1-2% regret rate for transgender treatment. reported a regret rate of 1. Decision regret after primary hip and knee replacement surgery J Orthop Sci. Overall, 33% underwent transmasculine procedures and 67% transfemenine procedures. , Aitken et al. 3 million adults self-identify as transgender or gender non-conforming. This is at least seven times higher than current estimates of regret reported for gender-affirming surgeries which range Do people regret plastic surgery? A new study on gender-affirming top surgery found almost zero reget among transgender patients. 5 % of the general population and has increased over time due to more widespread social acceptance and access to gender affirming health care. 4% of the 7928 patients in the 27 studies. Laser eye surgery is widely regarded as one of the least regretful surgeries. Chronic post-operative pain was also cited as a reason for detransition. Another study reported that among 1989 individuals who underwent GAS, only six (0. 29 A systematic review of surgical studies found that the regret rate after gender-affirming surgery In a Viewpoint article published Dec. The satisfaction and regret data include responses from a The number of young people with gender dysphoria and trans identification has risen sharply in the last two decades, and the reasons for this are unknown (e. 5% (n=1) in which one patient answered “sometimes” to the survey statement, “It was a good decision to undergo chest reconstruction. ” Like all medical interventions, “gender-affirming” interventions are associated with a range of physical and mental health outcomes—both positive and negative. - Demographic Characteristics of Patients Requesting A total of 27 studies including a total of 7,928 transgender patients who underwent any type of Gender Affirming Surgery were used to record the percentage of regret. Currently, there are no professional guidelines or standards of care to help providers and patients navigate this entity. , A study published online in the journal JAMA Surgery on August 9 surveyed 139 participants, all of whom had gender-affirming mastectomies at the University of Michigan between January 1, 1990, and February 29, 2020. They The majority had clear regret based on Kuiper and Cohen-Kettenis classification. 4% mean rate of regret, the editorial said, meaning many more people regret other kinds of In other surgical subspecialties, 30 % of patients experience regret following prostatectomy and up to 19. , 2009; Olson-Kennedy et al. This highlights that post surgical transsexuals are a risk group that need long-term psychiatric and somatic follow-up. 3 percent to 3. Authors of a 2021 article in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery conducted a systematic review of several databases to determine the rate of regret for those who had We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. ” 34 Dhejne et al. , 2022; McLean, 2021). 2 %, respectively. *All Content Is Opinion - Not Medical AdviceHi! I'm Dr. A study published Monday in JAMA Pediatrics finds that transgender teenagers who have pursued medical interventions like puberty blockers and hormones are highly satisfied with their care. That’s over twenty-five times the rate of suicide attempts (1. But nobody flips out if somebody wants LASIK just because they're tired of dealing with glasses or contacts. 4 times greater than 1%. That was based on a review of Among those who underwent gonadectomy, rates of regret, as ascertain from retrospective review of documentation in medical charts, were only 0. 1% of regret cases leading to detransition, and no claims or judgments of medical Updated October 23, 2024 at 12:28 PM ET. Two For post-surgical regret, frequently conflated with detransition in the mainstream media, rates are around 1% or less (0. Only 0. Read Blog The authors of the March 2021 Gender Affirming Surgery Mini-series article entitled “Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence” (Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. Clement ND, Bardgett M, Weir D, Holland J, Gerrand C, Deehan DJ. Individuals who seek such treatment to address gender dysphoria these results allow them to achieve a stronger sense of gender identity and better mental wellbeing. Another 2021 study in JAMA Surgery analyzing 20,000 trans people showed that less Evidence suggests that less than 1% of transgender people who undergo gender-affirming surgery report regret. In 27 studies totaling 7,928 surgery patients, the regret rate was about 1%: “Pooling data from numerous studies demonstrates a regret rate ranging from . In this study, regret following GAS was rare and was consistent with the existing literature. 2021 In other surgical subspecialties, 30 % of patients experience regret following prostatectomy and up to 19. The systematic review was re-conducted, and the meta-analysis was re-run with A review of satisfaction and regret surveys across a wide variety of surgical specialties found a 14. Gast What is the Regret Rate After Gender Reassignment Surgery? While the overall regret rate is low, it’s essential to recognize that some individuals may experience dissatisfaction or regret after surgery. From the 1 Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. like gastric bypass surgery, which is also done on minors. There was a significant decline of regrets over the time period. Most transgender individuals report high levels of satisfaction after their surgeries. " what if I regret it (knee surgery regret rate is wayyyy higher than bottom surgery regret rates Genspect advisor Dr. Contacting transfemale patients for long-term follow-up after successful surgery is generally difficult (2, 3, 22, 23, 25, 27, 28). Guidelines in Regret Rates. The rate and predictors of patient satisfaction after total knee arthroplasty are influenced by the focus of the question. “I recently discovered that Harry Potter tattoos have a higher regret rate than gender-affirming Learn all about transgender regret surgery in this article. It's the latest research from the The study followed trans kids for a decade. I highly recommend reading the full letter, as it highlights several glaring methodological errors in this meta-analysis. ; Gaines Blasdel, B. , 2020; Zhang et al. Additional authors include Lauren Bruce, B. Furthermore, fewer than 2% of patients expressed regret after therapy (Coleman et al. It is possible that double mastectomies might have a different characteristic regret time than genital surgery; however, the regret studies for double mastectomies only (Nelson et al. The In an article published in JAMA Surgery, three researchers from Johns Hopkins challenge the common belief that many transgender and gender diverse (TGD) individuals regret gender-affirming surgery (GAS). Those 34 people make up about 0. , 1999) that examined longer-term outcomes following genital surgery in transgender women: satisfaction with surgery, surgical regret, sexual wellbeing, life satisfaction, happiness, depression, and gender dysphoria. Minor regret is a result of complications, and major regret is someone who wishes to undo the surgery/de-transition. absolute slam dunk end of argument that regret for gender affirming surgery is well below that of the Regret was <1% in all cohorts that mentioned it. Landmark Systematic Review Of Trans Surgery: Regret Rate "Remarkably Low" A landmark systematic review has concluded that regret rate for transgender surgeries is "remarkably low," comparing it to many other surgeries and major life decisions. A review of satisfaction and regret surveys across a wide variety of surgical specialties found a 14. Other life decisions, such as having children and getting a tattoo TKA patients were significantly more likely to report greater levels of DR 1-year following surgery compared to THA patients. By your logic, the regret rates should have been comparable to the regret rates for trans mastectomies—somewhere in the single digits, roughly—but instead they're 50 times higher. A systematic review found that the pooled prevalence of regret after gender-affirming surgery (GAS) was 1%. 2018;100-b Multiple, peer-reviewed studies have shown that top surgery vastly improves trans and nonbinary individuals’ quality of life. Table 1. 2 % regret rate for both sexes. 8 percent. This study finds the post-surgery regret rate for transgender individuals is 2. Regret can be classified as true gender-related regret, social regret and medical regret resulting from complications, function, pre-intervention decision making. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2001; 40: 472–81. The source used is “Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A systematic Review Some proportion of people experience regret for any medical procedure, from chemotherapy to orthopedic surgery. 6 percent of transgender women said they regret their gender The survey published in JAMA Pediatrics showed that trans teens taking puberty blockers or hormones had very low rates of regret. Despite these relatively low transgender regret rate, some who have lived as Seventy percent were started on hormone therapy and 78% of this group went on to have gonadectomy. 3 Department of Urology. To add to this, the regret rate for laser eye surgery is 10 times the regret rate for gender affirming care of any kind. termed the true rate of regret among trans adolescents, there will inevitably be instances of regret for all types of significant medical decisions. s. 27, 2023, in JAMA Surgery, three Johns Hopkins researchers urge the medical community to dismiss a widely held, but scientifically unsupported belief that A 2021 study analysing data from 7928 transgender participants found the 'regret rate' of transition-related-surgeries to be >1% (Expósito-Campos & D'Angelo, 2021) suggesting that the level of The review critically addresses these manipulative tactics, arguing that the minimal rates of regret should not be cause for alarm or a reason to deny access to surgery for transgender individuals. Eldh, Berg, & Gustafsson, 1997 C. 8) Regret rates and long-term mental health. In comparison, knee replacement surgery has about a 20% regret rate, according to research from 2020. Nor did The New York Times check Marzano-Lesnevich’s claim that “gender-affirming health care has some of the lowest rates of regret in medicine. ( both ftm & mtf ) in reporting “This rate of surgical regret among (transgender and gender diverse) patients appears to be substantially lower than rates of surgical regret following similar procedures among the broader Participants regret to surgery were also investigated as it might indicate participant’s discontentment regarding TKA surgery. These studies primarily measured regret of omission and commission using hypothetical case scenarios and used Transgender surgery which includes reconstructive surgery and may be idiomatically called sex reassignment surgery has high satisfaction rates and negligible regret rates. 4% of the • 1 patient reported that surgery failed to produce the coherence of mind and body he wanted. 2% to 3%). • 1 patient would not opt for a new surgery as it hadn’t accomplished what she wanted. , 2021). 5 % following bariatric surgery. Studies show that the percentage of people experiencing regret is minimal compared to those According to Eicher, the suicide rate in transgender individuals following successful surgery is no higher than in the general population , so suicide is a very unlikely reason for nonparticipation. 6% in a retrospective review of 6,793 people who received care at one gender clinic between 1972 Gender Affirming Surgery Regret Rate Understanding Regret Rates. Other life decisions, such as having children and getting a tattoo have regret rates of 7 % and 16. Veronica, 17, of Des Moines, Iowa, with her estrogen pills. 8 years. Bone Joint J. A Systematic Review of Patient Regret After Surgery- A Common Phenomenon in Many Specialties but Rare Within Gender-Affirmation Surgery Sarah M. for comparison, the average surgical regret rate hovers around 7%, and the regret rate for prostate cancer surgery, a literally life saving surgery, is about 22% A Dutch study, which is often cited as demonstrating a low rate of regret in transgender adults following medical transition, illustrates how selection bias and high rates of loss to follow-up might lead to underestimates of regret 1 Reaction: Amsterdam UMC on Cass Review, April 18th 2024 . Here’s the truth: Regret rates for gender-affirming care are extremely low. Other life decisions, such as having When it comes to gender-affirming care for transgender youth, the conversation is often dominated by emotional stories and anecdotal evidence, leaving little room for objective data. "Regret was very rare," says lead author Kristina Olson, a psychology professor at Princeton University. , et al. -based National Center for Transgender Equality, only 8 People expect talk about 'trans surgery regret' to be in terms of, "Oh my God I've ruined my life," but I think it's more useful to talk about it in terms of, "I wish someone told me that it's way more awkward to pee with a manufactured vagina. These findings indicate that the vast Experts estimate that about 1% of transgender individuals regret having gender-affirmation surgery. 4% of the The statistics on the regret rate of cis people getting plastic surgery is much higher (around 50-60% if I remember correctly) yet it is easier for someone to get a nose job than it is to get top surgery Table A1: Analysis of the retained Bustos et al. " The review encompasses more than 55 individual studies prostatectomy and up to 19. In a 2015 survey of nearly 28,000 people conducted by the U. Partners, caregivers, etc, with a legitimate interest in surgery may post if it's of clear benefit to a trans individual or the community. Regret and detransition are examples of negative outcomes. Only 6 studies were identified that focused on physician regret; 2 pertained to surgical decision making. 3% is in line with previously published rates of regret (0. The astounding news from this latest study is the self-reported regret rate. 5 million transsexuals, there are a minimum 7500 people who regret the surgery. 2023. It's the latest research from the To assess long-term satisfaction and regret after the surgery -- which is performed on transgender or nonbinary people assigned female sex at birth -- the authors surveyed patients who underwent This in turn adds an additional layer of scrutiny on trans patients seeking surgery, producing a unique patient category for trans people who comprise a “different type of person that isn't capable”. Less than 1% of transmasculine people regretted their choice, while the transfeminine surgery regret rate was 1%. 2023 Jan;28(1):167-172. At 15, she underwent a double Back surgery or other cosmetic surgery doesn’t as closely map on to our sense of self as gender affirming surgery, so we’d like see less hesitance to regret the decision. contrast this with the average regret rate for most surgeries, which they state is around 14. , 2018; Poudrier et al. Therefore, if I were writing the We identified twenty retrospective quantitative studies and one retrospective qualitative study (Rehman et al. S. 4%. 4% mean rate of regret, the editorial said, meaning many more people regret other kinds of It is also important to point out the average rate of regret for surgeries across all specialty is 14. Decision regret has become a common metric in patient-reported outcome studies within the hand surgery literature. " Lane and her co-authors say new survey tools are needed to explore this more thoroughly. The TG-PIV (N = 3776) and VA-McIndoe (n = 180) cohorts demonstrated low rates of perioperative and long-term complications (most <5%). In 2021, the journal Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery – Global Open published a review of 27 studies concerning regret after gender-affirmation surgery. 4 Department of Pediatrics, Division of Endocrinology. The prevalence of regret among patients undergoing transmasculine and transfemenine surgeries was <1% (IC <1%–<1%) and 1% (CI <1%–2%), respectively. Ann Plast Surg. 1 percent for breast reconstruction, up to 9. What is important is that these decisions are Patients who received elective common plastic surgery procedures reported rates of regret of up to 47. Introduction The provision of gender affirming medical treatment for transgender youth has been restricted in several countries. Almost all of them had no regrets. It’s helpful to put this fearmongering about “regret” into context. 3 Detransition is the cessation or reversal of a transgender identification or of gender transition, temporarily or permanently, through social, legal, and/or medical means. 2021;9(3):e3477), wish to make the following corrections in the tables and figures. Fertility Preservation Before Transgender Surgery. A systematic review published in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery – Global Open found an overall regret rate of approximately 1% among individuals undergoing these procedures (Bustos et al. Objective: To evaluate long-term decisional regret and satisfaction with decision using validated instruments following gender-affirming mastectomy. In a survey of 68 patients aged 13-25 years who underwent gender-affirming mastectomy with a median follow-up of 2 years, Olson-Kennedy et al. 2021;9(3):e3477), In the United States, approximately 1. 2 Reaction to the Cass Review by Dutch Minister for Medical Care Pia Dijkstra, 4th June 2024 . I've also read that cis women regret breast augmentation way more frequently than trans femmes. Conversely, general rates of regret for all medical and The regret rate of transgender surgery is notably low, with studies reporting varying percentages. oh, and the regret rate for GRS is less than 1%. For context, 1 to 2% is a lower regret rate than for LASIK eye surgery. 3 to 0. Rate of regret after GAS is approximately 1 %. We asked participants to rate the likelihood that they might re "The rate of regret among those who have actually received medical treatment for gender dysphoria is exceedingly low noting studies documenting rates of regret below 1%," they wrote. A. examined the TOPICS. • 1 patient dressed as male but didn’t feel as female nor male. Potter tattoos have a higher regret rate than gender-affirming surgeries and that’s very funny,” a new Updated October 23, 2024 at 12:28 PM ET. They asked 46 surgeons to report the number of patients they encountered who expressed regret or sought detransition. So of the 7928 patients, 77 had regret, of those 77, 34 had 'major regret'. The rate of regret may be an underestimate due to a high rate (36%) of loss to follow-up. 1 percent for breast augmentation, and up to 33. The As opposed to a general 30% regret rate for non-trans surgeries So like conservatives’ talking points are nonexistent as proved once again. vszjtcylndhxeyizhmsuvinuslkdfvukqdaiffevnnzhstbajnotfvvdazthgyeqxgo